zero symfonie

[andremusic]

Hello, I am looking for the zero symfonie from Beethoven. Yes! The one he wrote before the first one. I already have his zero pianoconcerto. Who can help here?

[shostakovich]

I never heard of a zero symphony or a zero concerto by Beethoven. There used to be a "Jena" symphony attributed to him, but it is now attributed to Friedrich Witt. The only zero symphony I know about is by Bruckner. This should be an interesting topic to follow. I've heard of an "unbegun" symphony by PDQ Bach. Does that help?

[Peter]

<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by andremusic:<BR><B>Hello, I am looking for the zero symfonie from Beethoven. Yes! The one he wrote before the first one. I already have his zero pianoconcerto. Who can help here?</B><HR></BLOCKQUOTE>>><P>Beethoven sketched a C major symphony about 2 years after arriving in Vienna, and about 2 years before the bulk of his work on opus 21; however, I am not aware of any realised, performable version of the former. Are you sure that you`re not thinking of symphony no. 10, which at first glance, could look like no. 0?<P>Is your piano concerto no. 0, the one in E flat, WoO 4? Does it feature orchestration? If so, then by whom? As far as I know, any sketched orchestration by Beethoven is lost..........

[andremusic]

<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Peter:<BR><B>

Originally posted by andremusic:<BR>Hello, I am looking for the zero symfonie from Beethoven. Yes! The one he wrote before the first one. I already have his zero pianoconcerto. Who can help here?</B><HR></BLOCKQUOTE>>><P>Beethoven sketched a C major symphony about 2 years after arriving in Vienna, and about 2 years before the bulk of his work on opus 21; however, I am not aware of any realised, performable version of the former. Are you sure that you`re not thinking of symphony no. 10, which at first glance, could look like no. 0?<P>Is your piano concerto no. 0, the one in E flat, WoO 4? Does it feature orchestration? If so, then by whom? As far as I know, any sketched orchestration by Beethoven is lost..........

<P>Yes. In E Flat and it is performed with orchestration. Orchestration is from Willy Hess. Made somewere around 1900 I think.The ones from Beethoven are lost, yes.<BR>