Okay, lets see. Here's the recipe for
Hot Buttered Rum:
1 oz light rum
1 tsp sugar
1/2 tsp butter
4 cloves
Add the sugar, butter and cloves to a coffee mug. Pour the rum, and stir well. Fill with boiling water. Stir again, and serve.
And here's a recipe for
Hot Rum Toddy:
2 oz rum
1 tsp sugar
5 1/2 oz boiling water
Place a sugar cube or equivalent into an Irish coffee cup or mug. Fill 2/3 full with boiling water. Add rum and stir. Garnish with a slice of lemon, dust with nutmeg, and serve.
And the recipe for a
Hot Whiskey Toddy:
1 1/2 oz bourbon whiskey
1/4 oz lemon juice
3/4 oz sugar syrup
1 slice lemon
1 clove
4 oz hot water
Heat in a heat-resistant glass, and fill with hot water. Add a lemon slice speared with a clove, and serve.
Looks like the butter is the primary difference, based on these recipes. But my
Hot Whiskey Toddy recipe uses butter, so I guess it would probably be properly called a
Hot Buttered Whiskey.
I didn't see my recipe on line just doing a quick search. Mine comes from the
Mr. Boston's Bartenders Guide, which I've had for about twenty years or more. It's similar to the
Hot Whiskey Toddy recipe above, except that it uses butter and confectioner's sugar instead of sugar syrup.
V/R
Shapley