Beethoven.com

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:13 pm

And here is how everyone did based on accuracy (matching not considered):

bignaf 95.0%
navneeth 92.5%
Marye 88.0%
Serenity 80.0%
Shapley 75.0%
TrumpetMaster 74.0%
hal 9000 63.3%
Catmando 60.0%

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:13 pm

Full Results

Top Ten Symphonic Movements

47 Beethoven- Symphony 9, 4th mvt
24 Beethoven- Symphony 5, 1st mvt
21 Mahler- Symphony 5, 4th mvt
19 Beethoven- Symphony 7, 2nd mvt
19 Beethoven- Symphony 5, 4th mvt
18 Mozart- Symphony 40, 1st mvt
18 Beethoven- Symphony 9, 2nd mvt
17 Beethoven- Symphony 3, 2nd mvt
14 Beethoven- Symphony 7, 1st mvt
13 Dvorak- Symphony 9, 2nd mvt
13 Beethoven- Symphony 7, 4th mvt
12 Mahler- Symphony 1, 1st mvt
10 Dvorak- Symphony 9, 1st mvt
10 Mahler- Symphony 2, 1st mvt
09 Shostakovich- Symphony 5, 4th mvt
09 Beethoven- Symphony 6, 1st mvt
09 Mahler- Symphony 3, 1st mvt
09 Saint-Saëns- Symphony 3, 2nd mvt
09 Tchaikovsky- Symphony 5, 2nd mvt
09 Tchaikovsky- Symphony 6, 1st mvt
08 Berlioz- Symphonie fantastique- 5th mvt
08 Beethoven- Symphony 6, 2nd mvt
08 Mahler- Symphony 2, 4th mvt
08 Sibelius- Symphony 2, 4th mvt
07 Brahms- Symphony 1, 1st mvt
07 Mahler- Symphony 2, 5th mvt
06 Beethoven- Symphony 5, 2nd mvt
06 Dvorak- Symphony 9, 4th mvt
06 Mendelssohn- Symphony 4, 4th mvt
06 Mozart- Symphny 41, 4th mvt
05 Schubert- Symphony 8, 1st mvt
05 Sibelius- Finlandia
05 Sibelius- Symphony 7, 4th mvt
04 Tchaikovsky- Symphony 5, 1st mvt
04 Bruckner- Symphony 9, 2nd mvt
04 Mahler- Symphony 5, 5th mvt
04 Mendelssohn- Symphony 4, 1st mvt
04 Shostakovich- Symphony 8, 3rd mvt
03 Beethoven- Symphony 9, 3rd mvt
03 Brahms- Symphony 2, 4th mvt
03 Dvorak- Symphony 1, 1st mvt
03 Dvorak- Symphony 9, 3rd mvt
02 Haydn- Symphony 94, 1st mvt
02 Mahler- Symphony 5, 1st mvt
02 Schumann- Symphony 4, 3rd mvt
02 Sibelius- Symphony 1, 4th mvt
01 Beethoven- Symphony 6, 5th mvt
01 Dvorak- Symphony 7, 3rd mvt
01 Sibelius- Symphony 4, 3rd mvt
01 Stravinsky- Firebird Suite
01 Tchaikovsky- Symphony 4, 2nd mvt
01 Tchaikovsky- Symphony 4, 4th mvt

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:14 pm

Thank you everyone that submitted a list this time around. I hope you find the results as fun as I do. Hope to see everyone again on the next Top Ten thread, topic courtesy of ME!

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:14 pm

2nd List (#11-20) Results

There was not a single match among the 3 lists submitted that nominated the top 11 thru 20 symphonic movements, so I will just post the lists provided to me:

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:15 pm

Serenity

11. Mahler- Sym 4, 4th mvt
12. Sibelius- Sym 3, 1st mvt
13. Beethoven- Sym 3, 1st mvt
14. Shostakovich- Sym 5, 3rd mvt
15. Mahler- Sym 2, 3rd mvt
16. Saint-Saëns- Sym 3, 2nd mvt
17. Mendelssohn- Sym 4, 1st mvt
18. Mahler- Sym 9, 4th mvt
19. Beethoven- Sym 9, 1st mvt
20. Berlioz- Sym fantastique, 4th mvt

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:15 pm

Catmando

11. Mendelssohn- Sym 4, 2nd mvt
12. Beethoven- Sym 9, 4th mvt
13. Brahms- Sym 4, 1st mvt
14. Mahler- Sym 1, 3rd mvt
15. Beethoven- Sym 5, 4th mvt
16. Beethoven- Sym 4, 1st mvt
17. Beethoven- Sym 6, 1st mvt
18. Bruckner- Sym 4, 2nd mvt
19. Schumann- Sym 3, 1st mvt
20. Dvorak- Sym 8, 2

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:15 pm

TrumpetMaster

11. Dvorak- Sym 9, 4th mvt
12. Mahler- Sym 1, 1st mvt
13. Mahler- Sym 5, 5th mvt
14. Brahms- Sym 1, 1st mvt
15. Mozart- Sym 41, 4th mvt
16. Mendelssohn- Sym 5, 1st mvt
17. Mendelssohn- Sym 4, 4th mvt
18. Tchaikovsky- Sym 4, 1st mvt
19. Beethoven- Sym 3, 4th mvt
20. Brahms- Sym 4, 2nd mvt

by **hal 9000** » Mon Apr 09, 2007 7:16 pm

Opening the new thread now... this time we are going to do something a bit *different*... :twisted:

by **navneeth** » Tue Apr 10, 2007 4:12 am

hal, there appears to be two instances of Beethoven's 4th movt. from his 5th symphony in the main list.

I have only senn the title of the next topic(too eager to see these results

)... seems it may be as tough, if not tougher than this one.

by **hal 9000** » Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:12 am

navneeth wrote:hal, there appears to be two instances of Beethoven's 4th movt. from his 5th symphony in the main list.

I have only senn the title of the next topic(too eager to see these results )... seems it may be as tough, if not tougher than this one.

Look at my list, your list, and TrumpetMaster's list to find the 3 instances of Beethoven's 5th symphony, 4th movement.

:wink:

by **Catmando** » Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:16 am

hal 9000 wrote:
navneeth wrote:hal, there appears to be two instances of Beethoven's 4th movt. from his 5th symphony in the main list.

I have only senn the title of the next topic(too eager to see these results )... seems it may be as tough, if not tougher than this one.

Look at my list, your list, and TrumpetMaster's list to find the 3 instances of Beethoven's 5th symphony, 4th movement.

And don't forget, my list has it also. :wink:

by **hal 9000** » Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:20 am

Catmando wrote:
hal 9000 wrote:
navneeth wrote:hal, there appears to be two instances of Beethoven's 4th movt. from his 5th symphony in the main list.

I have only senn the title of the next topic(too eager to see these results )... seems it may be as tough, if not tougher than this one.

Look at my list, your list, and TrumpetMaster's list to find the 3 instances of Beethoven's 5th symphony, 4th movement.

And don't forget, my list has it also.

Umm, your list has Mahler's 5th symphony, 4th movement, but I do not see Beethoven's there.

by **Catmando** » Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:25 am

hal 9000 wrote:
Catmando wrote:
hal 9000 wrote:
navneeth wrote:hal, there appears to be two instances of Beethoven's 4th movt. from his 5th symphony in the main list.

I have only senn the title of the next topic(too eager to see these results )... seems it may be as tough, if not tougher than this one.

Look at my list, your list, and TrumpetMaster's list to find the 3 instances of Beethoven's 5th symphony, 4th movement.

And don't forget, my list has it also.

Umm, your list has Mahler's 5th symphony, 4th movement, but I do not see Beethoven's there.

Oops! You're right Hal. I was looking at my 11-20 list. :oops:

by **navneeth** » Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:48 am

I'm sorry, hal, my bad. Those 5's, 4's and 1's all bunched up together fooled my eyes. :oops:

Beethoven.com

Top Ten Symphonic Movements

Typically, which movement of a symphony do you prefer?

Who is online