30Q #58 - Trumpetmaster

[bignaf]

it didn't seem like Nav was asking about being 74 years old, he was stating that it has to be the case if the composer was born before the sinking of the Maine and and after discovery of the neutrino. though I don't think it has to be so. Neutrino was discovered in the 50's...
also take a look at a recap in the previous 30Q's, and try to make one like that. basically, in the recap it's nice to spell out the years, and eleminate questions that are no longer relevant.

[Trumpetmaster]

Is the composer either Vaughn-Williams or Sibelius?

Guesses do not count as questions.... so......

Vaughn-Williams - No

Sibelius - No

[bignaf]

guesses are only pieces, so that was a question. we usually allow question like that that eliminate two people, but we :frown: upon them.

[Trumpetmaster]

it didn't seem like Nav was asking about being 74 years old, he was stating that it has to be the case if the composer was born before the sinking of the Maine and and after discovery of the neutrino. though I don't think it has to be so. Neutrino was discovered in the 50's...
also take a look at a recap in the previous 30Q's, and try to make one like that. basically, in the recap it's nice to spell out the years, and eleminate questions that are no longer relevant.

Objection sustained....
I will adjust and subtract that er inquiry...



I'm a rookie at this so I will try add that info in the next recap....

Thanks!

I looked up nuetrino and it said it was discovered in 1930....

[Catmando]

I hope you were serious about the wink meaning that you were not serious about "question" #12.

Did the composer live to be an octogenarian?

Is this someone who only eats squid?

[navneeth]

Do we?

[Trumpetmaster]

I hope you were serious about the wink meaning that you were not serious about "question" #12.

Did the composer live to be an octogenarian?

Is this someone who only eats squid?

[navneeth]

I hope you were serious about the wink meaning that you were not serious about "question" #12.

Did the composer live to be an octogenarian?

Is this someone who only eats squid?

That's actually someone with eight limbs. Like a centaur with two hands to spare.

[Catmando]

Is the composer Russian?

[Trumpetmaster]

Updated Recap

1) Was work composed before Sinking of Shackleton's Endurance?
Research found Shackleton's Endurance sank in 1912.
Shapley - No

2) Is the trumpet a featured instrument?
Shapley - No

3) Was composer born in a country that borders the Rhine?
Shapley - No

4) Was the work composed after Nixon's resignation?
Nixon resigned in 1974
*ignaf - No

5) Was it composed before the discovery of Nuetrino?
I researched Neutrino and found it was discovered in 1930
(hope that website was correct)
Naveenth - No

Correction on #5 Neutrino discovered in 1950's , so the answer here
is Yes...

6) Was the composer born before the only Olympics in which cricket
was included?
Cricket was played one time in the 1900 Olympics
Naveenth - Yes (sorry, I'm trying to do this too fast....) this is a yes response

7) Was composer born after 1st ashes series?
1st Ashes series was 1877
Naveenth - Yes (made a mistake in my original response sorry)

#8 Was composer born in Western Hemispheere?
*ignaf - No


9) Was composer born before the sinking of the Maine?
Maine sank Feb 15 1898
Shapley - Yes

10) Does composition contain parts for strings and woodwinds?
Shapley - Yes

11) Does composition contain vocals?
Shapley - No

12) Was composer born in EU County?
*ignaf - Yes

13) Did composer live to be an octogenarian?
Naveenth - No

[navneeth]

I looked up nuetrino and it said it was discovered in 1930....

Uh-uh, that was the prediction, not the experimental disocovery (1956).

[Trumpetmaster]

I hope you were serious about the wink meaning that you were not serious about "question" #12.

Did the composer live to be an octogenarian?

Is this someone who only eats squid?

I won't count this/......

[Trumpetmaster]

I looked up nuetrino and it said it was discovered in 1930....

Uh-uh, that was the prediction, not the experimental disocovery (1956).

If this is the case then #5 - the work was composed before the discovery of Neutrino...

thanks........

[Trumpetmaster]

guesses are only pieces, so that was a question. we usually allow question like that that eliminate two people, but we :frown: upon them.

So should guesses be included as questions?

[Shapley]

Here is the recap - with dates:

1) Was work composed before Sinking of Shackleton's Endurance?
Shapley - No (15 November, 1915)
2) Is the trumpet a featured instrument?
Shapley - No
3) Was composer born in a country that borders the Rhine?
Shapley - No
4) Was the work composed after Nixon's resignation?
*ignaf - No (9 August, 1974)
5) Was it composed before the discovery of Nuetrino?
Naveenth - No (1959)
6) Was the composer born before the only Olympics in which cricket
was included?
Naveenth - No (1900)
7) Was composer born after 1st ashes series?
Naveenth - Yes (made a mistake in my original response sorry) (1882)
#8 Was composer born in Western Hemispheere?
*ignaf - No
9) Was composer born before the sinking of the Maine?
Shapley - Yes (15 February, 1898)
10) Does composition contain parts for strings and woodwinds?
Shapley - Yes
11) Does composition contain vocals?
Shapley - No
12) Was the composer at least 74 years old
Navneeth - No.

Wow! This is moving fast! By the time I'd typed this T/M had already updated it and several posts had followed. I will note that some of my dates don't mash with his. I hope this doesn't pose a problem!

[Catmando]

Is the composer Russian?

[navneeth]

TM, you're tasking yourself too much. A simple summary would do.

[Trumpetmaster]

Is the composer Russian?

14) Is the composer Russian?
No....

[Catmando]

guesses are only pieces, so that was a question. we usually allow question like that that eliminate two people, but we :frown: upon them.

So should guesses be included as questions?

No, guesses don't count as questions.

And you are only allowed 1 guess at a composition, unless you're name is Hexameron.

[Trumpetmaster]

Here is the recap - with dates:

1) Was work composed before Sinking of Shackleton's Endurance?
Shapley - No (15 November, 1915)
2) Is the trumpet a featured instrument?
Shapley - No
3) Was composer born in a country that borders the Rhine?
Shapley - No
4) Was the work composed after Nixon's resignation?
*ignaf - No (9 August, 1974)
5) Was it composed before the discovery of Nuetrino?
Naveenth - No (1959)

6) Was the composer born before the only Olympics in which cricket
was included?
Naveenth - No (1900) This is a YES... my error....

7) Was composer born after 1st ashes series?
Naveenth - Yes (made a mistake in my original response sorry) (1882)
#8 Was composer born in Western Hemispheere?
*ignaf - No
9) Was composer born before the sinking of the Maine?
Shapley - Yes (15 February, 1898)
10) Does composition contain parts for strings and woodwinds?
Shapley - Yes
11) Does composition contain vocals?
Shapley - No
12) Was the composer at least 74 years old
Navneeth - No.